The Philosopher
The instructional strategies we use are, in part, determined by our ideas
about how people learn. Your job is to look at the learning theories behind
the instructional models. They are as varied as the design models, but your job is to look
at the three primary views that support most of our learning
theories: behaviorism, constructivism and cognitivism (cognitive information processing).
Should we switch the order of the above paragraph with the next?
What can we say here that ultimately ties the student's activity here to the group think task?
In other words, something for them to keep in the back of their
mind as they work on these activities here.
Phase 1:
Your job as the Philosopher and truth-seeker is to sift through the volumes
of information about learning theories and refine and refocus that information
into manageable portions that relate to instructional design.
Lets create a matrix similar to the Modeler's in order to scaffold this critical thinking
a little more.
We have three primary views, behaviorism, constructivism and cognitivism. What distinguishes
one theory from another? In an article written by Peggy Ertmer and Timothy Newby, they used Schunk's
five definitive questions plus two more of their own to identify the characteristics of each
theory. Let's answer those questions for each of our theories in the following matrix.
You might find these web sites helpful:
| |
Behaviorism |
Cognitivism |
Constructivism |
| How does learning occur? |
| | |
| Which factors influence learning? |
| | |
| What is the role of memory? |
| | |
| How does transfer occur? |
| | |
| What types of learning are best explained by this theory? |
| | |
| What basic assumptions are relevant to ID? |
| | |
| How should instruction be structured to facilitate learning? |
| | |
Now, using these same resources, discuss the fundamental differences in the
role of the student in the learning process that each of these perspectives proposes.
Phase 2:
Now that you are the resident expert in learning theory, let’s take a look
at the design philosophy your team will present to the Board. Look at the
following web site:
We haven't reached the group activity portion of the task, so asking student to "discuss" probably
isn't appropriate here.
Should it be "what learning theory, or which learning theory?"
What about a question that asks whether learning theories are
mutually exclusive or can be blended?
Answer the following questions:
- Which learning theory or theories best support the ADDIE model? Why?
- How is this philosophy an advantage over the other viewpoints?
- Are learning theories mutually exclusive or can they be combined or blended
to meet individual project needs? Why or why not?
|